Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer #59 New York Giants Trading Card CGC NM 7.5
Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer #59 New York Giants Trading Card CGC NM 7.5 is backordered and will ship as soon as it is back in stock.
Fast Shipping
Fast Shipping
After payment is received, items will generally ship from Pristine Marketplace or our approved vendors within 2 business days. Please allow an additional 5-7 business days for custom framed jerseys.
Orders will ship via FedEx, UPS, or USPS for both domestic and international shipments.
60-Day Risk-Free Returns
60-Day Risk-Free Returns
Shop with total confidence. If you're not completely satisfied, return your item within 60 days for a full refund—no questions asked. Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed.
Authenticity Guaranteed
Authenticity Guaranteed
All signatures sold on Pristine Marketplace are 100% guaranteed authentic, offering buyers complete confidence in every purchase.
Each autographed item undergoes rigorous verification through trusted authentication providers—including Beckett Authentication Services (BAS), James Spence Authentication (JSA), Fanatics Authentic, or Pristine Auction’s own in-house standard, Pristine Authentic.
This unwavering commitment to authenticity protects collectors and fans alike, making every signed piece not just a display item, but a trusted investment.
Learn more
Fast & Secure Checkout
Description
Description
Collector Grade authenticated memorabilia card — not autographed or signed — 1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson graded CGC NM 7.5. An inaugural 1936 Hall of Fame inductee, Mathewson recorded 373 career wins (tied for third all-time) and a 2.13 ERA. He powered the New York Giants (MLB) to the 1905 title with three complete-game shutouts and 27 straight scoreless World Series innings.
Collector's Highlights:
- Athlete: Christy Mathewson
- Item: 1961 Fleer #59 trading card (New York Giants, MLB) — CGC NM 7.5
- Authentication: CGC Cards (encapsulated and graded)
Authenticated and encapsulated by CGC Cards, this vintage original carries a reliable third-party grade that helps protect condition and supports long-term value. A solid, collector-grade piece for any serious baseball memorabilia collection honoring one of the game’s true legends.

