Jim Kelly Signed 1987 Topps #362 Buffalo Bills Rookie Card PSA/DNA
Very low stock (2 units)$229Unit price /Unavailable-
Jim Kelly Signed 1987 Topps #72 Buffalo Bills Rookie Card BAS Auto 10
Very low stock (1 unit)$259Unit price /Unavailable-
Browse more Jim Kelly items:
Jim Kelly Trading Cards
Jim Kelly's trading cards span a career that reshaped what a franchise quarterback could accomplish in the postseason. His 1986 Topps rookie card — released the year he finally joined the Bills after his USFL stint — is one of the key cards from the era and a must-own for vintage football collectors. Kelly shares his rookie class with other legends of the late 1980s, but his four consecutive Super Bowl appearances give his cards a narrative weight that is truly unique in the hobby.
PSA and BGS graded options are available alongside raw cards. Kelly's vintage cards have appreciated steadily since his 2002 Hall of Fame induction, and high-grade examples remain in strong demand. Every purchase is backed by our 60-day return policy. See the full Jim Kelly memorabilia collection for jerseys, helmets, and more.
What is the most popular Jim Kelly card?
His 1986 Topps rookie card (#385) is the most iconic, with PSA 10 examples among the most prized vintage football cards from the decade.
Are cards authenticated?
All signed cards include a COA and tamper-evident hologram. Graded cards come in their official PSA or BGS slab.