Don Mattingly Baseballs

Don Mattingly Autographed Baseballs

Hold a piece of Yankees history with an authenticated Don Mattingly signed baseball from Pristine Marketplace. A signed baseball is the quintessential collectible in the hobby, and when that signature belongs to Donnie Baseball — the 1985 AL MVP who hit .307 for his career and won nine consecutive Gold Glove Awards — the appeal is undeniable. Every baseball in our collection is verified by authentication partners including PSA, JSA, and Beckett, and ships with a Certificate of Authenticity and tamper-evident hologram.

Don Mattingly autographed baseballs are among the most popular items for Yankees collectors and fans of 1980s baseball. His signature carries the weight of six All-Star selections, three Silver Slugger Awards, and a retired #23 in the Bronx. Whether displayed on its own in a case or as the centerpiece of a broader collection alongside signed bats and authenticated jerseys, a Mattingly-signed baseball connects you directly to one of the most beloved Yankees of all time. All purchases are backed by our 60-day return policy.

Explore the complete Don Mattingly memorabilia collection for trading cards, photos, and more.