Free Shipping on U.S. Orders $99+!
1 3

Tennessee Peyton Manning Signed 3x5 Index Card w/ Vintage Signature PSA Slabbed

$829

⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑ 4.8/5 Stars from Real Collectors

Free Shipping on U.S. Orders $99+

After payment is received, items will generally ship from Pristine Marketplace or our approved vendors within 2 business days. Please allow an additional 5-7 business days for custom framed jerseys.

Orders will ship via FedEx, UPS, or USPS for both domestic and international shipments.

60-Day Risk-Free Returns

Shop with total confidence. If you're not completely satisfied, return your item within 60 days for a full refund—no questions asked. Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed.

100% Authenticity Guaranteed

All signatures sold on Pristine Marketplace are 100% guaranteed authentic, offering buyers complete confidence in every purchase.

Each autographed item undergoes rigorous verification through trusted authentication providers—including Beckett Authentication Services (BAS), James Spence Authentication (JSA), Fanatics Authentic, or Pristine Auction’s own in-house standard, Pristine Authentic.

This unwavering commitment to authenticity protects collectors and fans alike, making every signed piece not just a display item, but a trusted investment.

Learn more

Fast & Secure Checkout

  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

Own a rare piece of college football history with this Peyton Manning Autographed 3x5 Index Card featuring his vintage signature from his time with the Tennessee Volunteers. A must-have for any serious collector or fan of one of the greatest quarterbacks in NCAA and NFL history, this item offers both nostalgic value and solid investment potential. Meticulously preserved and authenticated, this unique autograph is encapsulated by PSA/DNA, ensuring its long-term protection and authenticity verification via the Professional Sports Authenticator website.

  • Personally signed by Peyton Manning during his collegiate years with the Tennessee Volunteers
  • Rare vintage signature — a collector’s gem reflecting Manning’s early football legacy
  • 3x5 index card — compact, display-ready size ideal for framing or archival storage
  • Authenticated and slabbed by PSA/DNA — 100% verified and tamper-proof
  • Authentication details can be cross-checked on the Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA/DNA) website
This item is more than just an autograph. It’s a tribute to Peyton Manning’s remarkable college career—a period that set the foundation for his Hall of Fame NFL legacy. Display it with pride or add it to your memorabilia collection—either way, this authentic piece makes a powerful statement.
Back to top