- New arrivalVery low stock (1 unit)$599Unit price /Unavailable
-
- New arrivalVery low stock (1 unit)$539Unit price /Unavailable
-
Dale Murray Autographed 1984 Fleer Card #134 New York Yankees SKU #265153
Very low stock (1 unit)$79Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1984 Topps Card #697 New York Yankees SKU #264073
Very low stock (1 unit)$89Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1985 Fleer Card #137 New York Yankees SKU #264093
Very low stock (1 unit)$79Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1985 Fleer Card #137 New York Yankees SKU #264094
Very low stock (1 unit)$79Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1985 Topps Card #481 New York Yankees SKU #264113
Very low stock (1 unit)$89Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1984 Fleer Card #134 New York Yankees SKU #263975
Very low stock (1 unit)$79Unit price /Unavailable-
Dale Murray Autographed 1984 Donruss Card #577 New York Yankees SKU #263953
Very low stock (1 unit)$79Unit price /Unavailable-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$719Unit price /Unavailable
-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$1,319Unit price /Unavailable
-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$1,199Unit price /Unavailable
-
Joe Sewell Autographed 1961 Fleer Card #76 New York Yankees PSA/DNA #83312489
Very low stock (1 unit)$59Unit price /Unavailable-
Joe Sewell Autographed 1961 Fleer Card #76 New York Yankees PSA/DNA #83312488
Very low stock (1 unit)$59Unit price /Unavailable-
Joe Sewell Autographed 1961 Fleer Card #76 New York Yankees PSA/DNA #83312487
Very low stock (1 unit)$59Unit price /Unavailable-
Yankees Mariano Rivera Authentic Signed 1992 Bowman #302 Rookie Card BAS Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)$509Unit price /Unavailable-
Yankees Aaron Judge Signed 2020 Topps Tier One Relics #T1RAJ Card BAS Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)$1,279Unit price /Unavailable-
Yankees Mickey Mantle Signed Custom Trading Card Auto Grade Mint 9! BAS Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)$2,849Unit price /Unavailable-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$7,199Unit price /Unavailable
-
Billy Martin Autographed 1953 Bowman Color Card #118 New York Yankees Beckett BAS #18969319
Very low stock (1 unit)$359Unit price /Unavailable-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$839Unit price /Unavailable
-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$839Unit price /Unavailable
-
- Very low stock (1 unit)$779Unit price /Unavailable
-
Yankees Derek Jeter Authentic Signed 1993 Excel #106 Rookie Card BAS Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)$639Unit price /Unavailable-
Browse more New York Yankees items:
New York Yankees Trading Cards
New York Yankees trading cards represent the richest history in baseball card collecting. From the legendary 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle — the most iconic baseball card ever printed — to modern Aaron Judge Topps Chrome and Bowman releases, Yankees cards span over a century of the hobby. Pristine Marketplace carries over 500 graded and raw Yankees cards, including PSA and BGS slabbed vintage issues, autograph inserts, and modern parallels featuring Hall of Famers and current stars.
Every card is guaranteed authentic and backed by our 60-day return policy. Explore the full New York Yankees memorabilia collection or browse signed baseballs and autographed photos.
What New York Yankees trading cards are most valuable?
High-grade vintage cards command the strongest values — particularly the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle, pre-war Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig issues, and 1950s-era Bowman cards. Modern Aaron Judge rookies in PSA 10 and Derek Jeter prospect cards are also highly sought after.
Are New York Yankees cards on Pristine Marketplace authenticated?
Yes. Every New York Yankees card is guaranteed authentic. Graded cards include their PSA or BGS slab with hologram verification, and raw autographed cards ship with a Certificate of Authenticity.