Skip to content

Free Shipping on U.S. Orders $99+!

Shop the Top Deals of the Week Shop Now

Authenticity Guarantee

Country/Region

United States (USD $)

Search

Menu

NFL
MLB
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
College
Other Sports
Trading Cards
Pop Culture
Display
Deals

Home
MLB Memorabilia Under $5,000

MLB Memorabilia Under $5,000

(151 products)

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

View as List Grid

FiltersFilter & Sort

Applied Filters

Clear all

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Athlete

Clear

Team

Atlanta Braves
Boston Red Sox
Chicago Cubs
Cincinnati Reds
Cleveland Guardians
Detroit Tigers
Green Bay Packers
Houston Astros
Los Angeles Angels
Los Angeles Dodgers
New York Mets
New York Yankees
Ottowa Senators
Philadelphia Phillies
Pittsburgh Pirates
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
Seattle Mariners
St. Louis Cardinals
Texas Rangers

Clear

Sport

Baseball

Clear

League

MLB

Clear

Authenticator

Beckett
JSA
PSA

Clear

Grade

2
4
7
8
9
10

Clear

Price

From $

-

To $

From To

Clear

Product Type

Baseballs
Bats
Cuts
Documents
Footballs
Gloves
Index Cards
Jerseys
Lithographs
Magazines
Patches
Photos
Postcards
Posters
Programs
Scorecards
Seats
Tickets
Trading Cards
unclassified

Clear

Ships Free
New arrival
Jim Bottomley Autographed 3x5 Index Card St. Louis Cardinals Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS #13264804
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,539

View details
Ships Free
New arrival
George Kell Autographed 1949 Bowman Rookie Card #26 Detroit Tigers PSA 4 Auto Grade Mint 9 PSA/DNA #103714231
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,759

View details
100% Authenticity Guaranteed
All signatures sold on Pristine Marketplace are guaranteed authentic, offering buyers complete confidence in every purchase.
Learn More
Ships Free
New arrival
Ken Griffey Jr. & Sr. Autographed Aug. 31st, 1990 First Father/Son Game Ticket Stub Seattle Mariners PSA 8 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 (Highest Graded) PSA/DNA #92328119
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,739

View details
Ships Free
1969 Mets (23) Ryan, Berra, Seaver, Koosman +19 Signed Seatback BAS #AE13780
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,809

View details
Ships Free
Hall of Famers and Stars Hank Greenberg Signed Auto Baseball JSA LOA ZZ63164
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
500 Home Run HR Club Autographed Framed 28x30 Photo With 11 Signatures Including Willie Mays & Hank Aaron Beckett BAS #AB08915
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,299

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle Autographed 1952 Topps Porcelain Rookie Card New York Yankees Auto Grade Mint 9 PSA/DNA #AR06114
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
1961 New York Yankees Team Autographed Official AL Baseball World Series Champs Auto Grade Mint 9 With 34 Signatures Including Mickey Mantle Beckett BAS #18284892
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,539

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle & Roger Maris Autographed Framed 11x17 Poster New York Yankees Vintage Signature Beckett BAS #AE31085
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,359

View details
Ships Free
Walter Johnson & Joe Cronin Autographed 1932 Washington Senators Scorecard Beckett BAS #AE25471
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,299

View details
Ships Free
Red Sox Carlton Fisk Signed 1975 World Series Game 6 Ticket Stub PSA/DNA Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,809

View details
Ships Free
Carlton Fisk Signed 1975 World Series Game 6 Ticket Stub Auto 10! PSA/DNA Slab 1
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,809

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle New York Yankees 1960s Signed American League Baseball PSA/DNA LOA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
2016 Chicago Cubs Team Signed Cubs Joe Maddon 2016 WS Patch White Pinstripe Majestic Jersey w/WS MVP (26 Sigs)
Low stock (4 units)

$2,779

View details
Ships Free
Nolan Ryan Autographed 1968 Topps Rookie Card #177 New York Mets PSA 5 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #64992680
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,599

View details
Ships Free
Albert Pujols & Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 2001 Topps Traded Rookie Card #T99 PSA 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #60417725
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,879

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle Autographed Official AL Baseball New York Yankees Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS #9373580
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,199

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle Autographed Official AL Baseball New York Yankees Auto Grade Mint 9 "No 7." Beckett BAS #17801733
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
1950s Dodgers Jackie Robinson, Hoyt Wilhelm, +5 Signed Album Page JSA #ZZ21264
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,849

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle & Joe Namath Authentic Signed 8x10 Photo Autographed BAS Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Willie Mays Autographed 1959 Topps Card #464 San Francisco Giants Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 "The Catch" Beckett BAS #14172644
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,739

View details
Ships Free
Ken Griffey Jr. Autographed 1989 Seattle Mariners 1st HR Ticket Stub Seattle Mariners PSA 8 MK Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 "4-10-89" PSA/DNA #92328118
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,739

View details
Ships Free
Yankees Mickey Mantle "No. 7" Authentic Signed OAL Baseball UDA #UDM18621
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,699

View details
Ships Free
Roberto Clemente Autographed 1971-72 4x5.5 Photo Pittsburgh Pirates Beckett BAS #17607631
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,799

View details
Ships Free
Giants Willie Mays Signed 1960 Topps AS #564 Card Grade VG-EX 4 Auto 8 PSA Slab
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
Mickey Mantle Mike Trout Signed American League Baseball JSA Z95954
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
1972 Pittsburgh Pirates World Series Champion Team Autographed Official Feeney NL Baseball With 28 Signatures Including Roberto Clemente Beckett BAS #AE08165
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,539

View details
Ships Free
Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 1993 BBM Rookie Card #239 Orix Blue Wave PSA 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Signed In Kanji PSA/DNA #73045475
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,599

View details
Ships Free
Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 1993 Takara Rookie Card #51 Orix Blue Wave PSA 5 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Signed In Kanji PSA/DNA #96081339
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 1993 Takara Rookie Card #51 Orix Blue Wave Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Signed In Kanji PSA/DNA #96410010
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
1953 New York Yankees World Series Champs Team Autographed Official Harridge AL Baseball With 21 Signatures Including Mickey Mantle (Vintage) Beckett BAS #AE08360
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Robert Clemente Rookie Signed 1955 Pirates NL Baseball + 27 Others JSA LOA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,449

View details
Ships Free
Bill McKechnie Autographed Artvue Hall of Fame HOF Plaque Postcard Cincinnati Reds Beckett BAS #13575591
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,299

View details
Ships Free
1964-65 Green Bay Packers Team Autographed Official Playoff Program With 26 Signatures Including Vince Lombardi & Bart Starr PSA/DNA & Beckett BAS #AP06274
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,699

View details
Ships Free
Roger Maris Signed Framed New York Yankees 8x10 Baseball Photo BAS LOA AB80415
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
Mantle, Berra Ford & More 1961 Yankees W.S Champs Team Signed 8x10 Photo JSA LOA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Chase Utley 2005 Season Philadelphia Phillies Game Used Sam Bat Baseball Bat PSA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,829

View details
Ships Free
Alex Rodriguez Signed Texas Rangers Game Used Louisville Bat Game Used Insc PSA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,809

View details
Ships Free
1970 New York Yankees Team Signed Baseball Thurman Munson + 20 Others JSA LOA
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,079

View details
Ships Free
1999 New York Yankees Signed Cooperstown Bat Jeter Rivera & More BAS AC22625
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,549

View details
Ships Free
Yankees Mickey Mantle HOF 74 Authentic Signed Baseball OAL JSA #B20710
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,499

View details
Ships Free
Dodgers Don Drysdale Signed 1957 Topps #18 Rookie Card Ex 5, Auto 8 PSA Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)

$4,469

View details
Ships Free
1966 Green Bay Packers Team Signed Autographed Framed 16x20 Photo With 34 Signatures Including Bart Starr Beckett BAS #AD78728
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Pirates Honus Wagner Authentic Signed 1x3.75 Cut Signature PSA/DNA Slabbed
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,319

View details
Ships Free
1961 World Series Champions New York Yankees Autographed Framed 8x10 Photo With 27 Signatures Including Mickey Mantle JSA #BB89296
Very low stock (1 unit)

$2,999

View details
Ships Free
Dodgers Sandy Koufax Cy Young 1963, 1965, 1966 Signed Oml Baseball JSA #XX26864
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,319

View details
Ships Free
300 Win Club Autographed Jersey With 8 Signatures Including Nolan Ryan, Tom Seaver and Warren Spahn JSA #XX71926
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,299

View details
Ships Free
Robin Roberts Autographed 1949 Bowman Rookie Card #46 Philadelphia Phillies Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #82480299
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,539

View details
Ships Free
Roger Maris Autographed 1958 Topps Rookie Card #47 New York Yankees PSA/DNA #84788097
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,359

View details
Ships Free
Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 2001 Donruss Elite Status Rookie Card #195 Seattle Mariners BGS 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 "01 ROY/MVP" Beckett BAS #16613816
Very low stock (1 unit)

$3,359

View details

Previous
Page 1 / 4
1
2
3
4
Next

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Subtotal:$0 USD

Loading...

Looking for authentic sports memorabilia and signed collectibles? Check out Pristine Marketplace for rare finds from your favorite NFL, MLB, NBA, and NHL teams and players. Shop with confidence knowing every item is meticulously authenticated for quality and value. Start your collection today!

Facebook
YouTube
Instagram

Support

FAQ
Refund Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Online Dispute Resolution (EU)

Pristine Marketplace

Authenticity Guaranteed
About Us
Contact Us
Wholesale Signup
Blog

Quick Links

NFL Memorabilia
MLB Memorabilia
NBA Memorabilia
NHL Memorabilia
NASCAR Memorabilia
Pop Culture
Trading Cards
Funko Pops!
Frames & Display Cases
Top Deals

Payment methods accepted

© 2025 Pristine Marketplace.

Choose options

Item added to your cart.

View cart

1

Add to cart

Remove all